I went to a town hall meeting sponsored by McCaskill’s office on Monday night. McCaskill was not there - some of her office people conducted it, and no, I don’t believe they get it.
When the meeting started (I would estimate a crowd of 500 crammed into a small branch public library), they didn’t even have a microphone. They had to scramble for the library’s very inefficient one, explaining they were only expecting 20 people. (Surely, the Senator herself must have known better. I can’t speak for her office staff).
Initially they weren’t even going to have a town hall meeting, but only allow people to approach the aides one at a time to register their questions, which would then be passed on to “Claire”. The people would have nothing to do with that set-up and essentially told them (loudly) “we were promised a town hall meeting and we are going to have a town hall meeting”, and it would be up to them if they wanted to participate in it.
I didn’t count the questions nor write them all down, but it was evident that the real issue here is frustration and fear, mixed with anger. That is something that doesn’t need to be explained – many of you have the same emotions. Granted, many of the questions (and comments I heard from the people standing around me) are misunderstandings, but on the other hand many were incisive, well thought out, and well-reasoned. The aides only had talking points for answers, which of course added to the frustration and anger.
The politicians really don’t understand why people are frustrated. Their constituents really don’t like elitism, they don’t want government to be God, they are scared to death of deficits and loss of sovereignty to foreign creditors (which came up as one of the questions), and they don’t want healthcare to be run like the post office (which Mr. Obama actually compared his plan to recently). In short, people are worried for their kids (passing on the blessings of liberty to the next generation) and for their elderly parents (the govt. has no business being involved in end of life counseling).
Clearly the people in the meeting were a politically unpolished mix of white collar and blue collar types, but that’s really the whole point. They are tired of being called unpatriotic astro-turfers. They are tired of being condescended to by the people who are supposed to be working for them. And now, finally, they are willing to stand up and be counted to protect their liberties.
Personally, I am of a mixed mind on what is going on. The poor McCaskill staffer had to endure a battering for 1-1/2 hours, and handled it much better than I would have. She did not deserve to be put in front of a crowd like this when it is her boss that the people wanted to confront. The Senator should not have thrown her under the bus like that.
But still, what is happening now parallels something I was involved in (and others on this forum have been too) in the mid-1990s. This town hall meeting and the underlying debate about the powers that be and the people has an uncanny feel for my last years in the big corporate churches. We have arrogant leadership who put on a show of listening but who already had their minds made up. We have leadership who, if they think it’s good for you, will attempt to do it to you. We have double-talk and new-speak with the thought that they can actually blow it by us. We have leaders who want to control information (“don’t listen to so-and-so” type of comments), and people who know how to get the information anyway.
This comment says it all: “You work for us. We don’t work for you.”
Things are getting interesting, and frankly, the establishment needs to be very concerned. These people are not going away because it’s not really about healthcare. It’s about a whole lot more. This is big. Really big.